Photo: Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic for iHeartMedia
Caelynn Miller-Keyeshas four engagement rings… yes, four.
TheBachelor in Paradisestar, 27, opened up on her podcastHelp! We Suck At Being Newlywedswith beauDean Unglert, 32, andJared Haibon, 34, about receiving her fourth engagement ring from Unglert and why she has acquired so much wedding bling.
Just as their May 1st episode was coming to a close, Unglert jumped in and said, “Oh, I gave Caelynn her new engagement ring,” before encouraging her to show it off for the camera.
Miller-Keyes holds it up for the camera, saying that her new ring is “so pretty” before Haibon asked Unglert, “So you bought a brand new ring?”
John Salangsang/Shutterstock
Unglert then explained that he “got a sponsored ad from Brilliant Earth” and thanked the brand for the sponsorship, saying, “Thank you very much for supplying the ring.”
The conversation made Miller-Keyes confess that “It is my, uh, fourth ring.” To which her soon-to-be husband jokingly added, “Her fourth ring and definitely her last.”
Haibon then pried more info out of the couple about why she had four rings. Miller-Keyes replied, “I’ve got the one I’m wearing, this is number four, number three was the replica, number two is my middle finger that he proposed with, and number one is still lost.”
Their co-host was still confused, needing more information about “Where did the third one come from?”
Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
Ungler then confessed, “I wanted you to secretly be like, ‘I don’t care. I love it so much’ " to which Miller-Keyes doubled down, saying, “I said I don’t care, and you’re like ‘no.'”
The hilarious confession comes afterthe couple got engaged in October of last yearin a scenic display of love on the beach of the Hawaiian island of Kauai.
Sara Jaye Weiss/Shutterstock
“It might be in the garage somewhere, but yeah, the moral of the story is don’t put your engagement rings in the junk drawer,” Ungler said on the same podcast. “So I did have to go out and buy a placeholder ring for now, but it’s not quite as nice as the first one was.”
Three rings later, in February of this year, the couple announced they would tie the knot on a ranch in Colorado.
“I couldn’t imagine a more perfect place to marry this perfect guy,” Miller-Keyes captioned a sneak peek of their wedding venue onInstagram.
source: people.com
